I read Prep: A Novel the other day after having read two other books set at private schools, Special Topics in Calamity Physics and Gentlemen and Players, within the last month. I remember there being a lot of debate/discussion in the blogosphere over Prep when it came out but I didn't really pay much attention to it. Maybe it was the cover that turned me off. After reading it, I'm not sure what all the fuss was about. It seemed very Young Adult Novel to me--sort of a "beach read" (And after googling Sittenfeld just now to see what other bloggers thought, I find that at least one reader/writer I know agrees).
Sittenfeld definitely gets the insecure teen thrust into an alien environment, but I don't feel like I learned anything new or received any real benefit from reading it. In some ways the main character Lee reminded me of Nick in the incomparably better (though perhaps longer than it needed to be) novel The Line of Beauty. Both are keen observers, take everything personally, and imbue all whom they meet with the most negative impulses and motives.
As for Special Topics, it was miles ahead creatively and great fun for a word lover, but I found it lacking in the character department. I guess I expected more after the initial charm began to wear off. I'll be anxious to read the author's next novel to see how she develops as a writer. I started The Moon and Sixpence yesterday. It feels so luxurious to read something this beautiful and elevating after Prep. It's like eating a soufflé that took two hours to make after having just scarfed down a Twix.
P.S. What do you think about publishers adding "a novel" to titles? In general it seems redundant and affected but there's also something 18th century about it that is nice for certain books.